A Pittsburgh-Area Church Grew Nearly 6,300 Hot Peppers for Pantry Families This Year, and Its New Garden Is Two and a Half Times Bigger

The last peppers have been picked at Bower Hill Community Church in Mt. Lebanon, Pennsylvania, and the count is in. In a harvest update posted Oct. 29, the church said its garden donated nearly 6,300 peppers this year, about 300 pounds in all, to families who get groceries through the South Hills Interfaith Movement, the food and social services agency in Pittsburgh’s southern suburbs known as SHIM.
Many of those peppers were the kind that make cooks cautious. Alongside familiar varieties, the garden has grown Carolina Reapers and ghost peppers, according to a profile SHIM published Oct. 28. The heat is the point. The garden was planted for neighbors who wanted it.
This year the congregation also built something new: a second garden on its front lawn, roughly two and a half times the size of the original, ready for its first full season next spring.
A garden planted for refugee kitchens
The original plot went in more than a decade ago with a specific purpose, SHIM wrote: growing vegetables that would mean something to the refugee families the agency serves. Volunteers learned that many of those families liked to cook with hot peppers, so the church grew hot peppers, and has kept growing them ever since.
The planting is a congregation-wide project. In spring, the church asked members to help cover the cost of 124 pepper plants at $2 each. Its newsletter said the plants were ordered through Dean’s Greenhouse in a purchase that would benefit the youth group’s mission projects. By late May, members had sponsored 77 of them.
Alan Hohlfelder, a longtime volunteer whom SHIM describes as the garden’s champion, sees the need from more than one side. “I volunteer at the Greater Pittsburgh Community Food Bank and SHIM, and you see the need,” he told the agency. “When you’re packing 300-plus boxes per week, you realize how much need there really is.”
His ties to SHIM run through his family. According to the agency, his father-in-law, Bob Davis, and his wife, Betsy, both served on SHIM’s board of directors, and Betsy also volunteered in its after-school programs. “Since I’ve been married, we’ve been doing stuff at SHIM,” he said.
Spending an anniversary on neighbors
The bigger garden grew out of the church’s 75th anniversary. When leaders planned the celebration, SHIM reported, they wanted to invest in the future rather than only look back. The congregation set aside 25% of its anniversary capital campaign for mission projects, up from the 10% it had traditionally designated, and expanding the garden was one of the projects chosen.
The church’s large front lawn offered the space. In its March newsletter, the congregation’s Eco-Justice Team said the expanded garden would be more visible, as well as beautiful and accessible, so people could enjoy it even if they weren’t working in it. That newsletter credited funds from the capital campaign, help from a Montessori school and donations from local businesses.
Building it took most of the year. With guidance from SHIM’s garden coordinator, Becky, volunteers worked through fencing, planting containers, watering and the question every suburban gardener eventually faces: how to keep wildlife from eating everything. A $1,000 grant from Grow Pittsburgh helped buy supplies, SHIM said, and Evey Hardware donated the use of equipment the church would otherwise have rented.
Volunteers spent months installing fencing, digging trenches and building raised planting areas, with underground barriers against groundhogs and mesh against deer, rabbits and squirrels.
At least 25 members of the congregation pitched in, SHIM reported, along with Boy Scout Troop 28 and Cub Scout Pack 28, parents, and children from the church’s Vacation Bible School. The children helped with construction and picked peppers from the original garden, a hands-on way to learn where a food pantry’s fresh produce comes from.
“It truly took a village to accomplish all that we did this year,” the church’s harvest update said, calling the project a way to “let our light shine” in the anniversary year.
A quiet place, and a thin one
Karl Casey, a master gardener trained through Pittsburgh’s Phipps Conservatory, joined at Hohlfelder’s invitation. He is especially interested in teaching, SHIM wrote. Plans call for a central seating area that can serve as an outdoor classroom where youth groups and neighbors can learn about gardening, healthy food and environmental stewardship. The church is also exploring partnerships with the Western Pennsylvania Conservancy and the Mt. Lebanon Conservancy to ring the garden with native plants.
“It’s a quiet space. It allows you to connect,” Casey told SHIM. According to the agency, a trip to Haiti changed how he saw communities facing hardship and eventually led him to become a lay minister and help coordinate a ministry serving people experiencing poverty and homelessness.
SHIM recounted that after hearing a sermon about “thin spaces,” places where people feel especially close to God, he realized the garden was one of those places for him. He finds meaning in the whole cycle, from seeds in spring to harvest months later, and knowing the food will reach families in need keeps him coming back.
Caring for creation shows up elsewhere in the church’s calendar, too. Its May newsletter reported that a large group of Bower Hill volunteers joined a planting in the riparian area of Mt. Lebanon’s Twin Hills Park that put in 45 trees, 147 shrubs and 164 perennials, replacing ground dominated by invasive honeysuckle, privet and viburnum. Each spring the church also staffs a pot-a-plant station for children at the community’s Earth Day celebration.
Who the peppers reach
SHIM runs food pantries in Bethel Park, Baldwin and West Mifflin, stocking canned goods, produce, bread, milk, eggs and frozen meat, Pittsburgh public radio station 90.5 WESA reported in February. At that time the agency said its pantries served roughly 4,100 people a month. In its October profile of the garden, SHIM put the figure at more than 4,400 people each month, including working families, older adults and children.
WESA reported that most households SHIM serves include at least one working family member, and that the agency had installed 16 temperature-controlled food lockers at its Bethel Park center so people could pick up groceries on nights and weekends. “We’re trying to reach as many people as possible,” Molly Penderville, SHIM’s basic needs director, told the station.
Hohlfelder and Casey hope the garden helps break down assumptions about who needs a pantry. “Anybody can end up in a situation, for one reason or another, where they’re looking for food assistance,” Hohlfelder told SHIM. He remembered a family who needed help after a house fire left them without a kitchen. Others face medical bills, job losses or rising household costs. Casey noted that hardship can be harder to see in suburban communities, and that stigma keeps some neighbors from asking for help.
Next spring’s planting
Hot peppers will stay, but the new beds give the church room for more. Volunteers plan to add squash, zucchini, eggplant and green beans, and to check with SHIM’s garden coordinator about which produce families need most and what other community gardens already grow.
The church also wants to make helping easier. Instead of asking for a season-long commitment, it hopes to set up short harvest shifts, so a family could stay an hour after Sunday worship to pick vegetables bound for SHIM. The harvest update promised plenty of chances to help with prep, planting and harvesting next year.
For now, the beds are resting through a western Pennsylvania winter: one small garden that has fed refugee kitchens for more than a decade, and a larger one beside it that has not yet grown a single pepper. The fencing and groundhog barriers are in. In spring, the congregation will find out how much more a front lawn can give.
Sources: South Hills Interfaith Movement (SHIM), “Growing More Than Food: Local Church Expands Garden to Support Neighbors,” Oct. 28, 2026; Bower Hill Community Church posts “SHIM Garden Harvest Update” (Oct. 29, 2026), “SHIM Garden Season is Starting!” (May 2026), “Intergenerational Opportunities – May 2026” and “Eco-Justice Team – April 2026”; Kate Giammarise, 90.5 WESA, “Food lockers aim to expand food pantry access in Pittsburgh’s South Hills,” Feb. 3, 2026. Cover photo: ornamental pepper plant, U.S. Department of Agriculture, public domain via Wikimedia Commons.



Comments